Snow/ice removal consists of plowing snow and
ice from bridges, roadways, and shoulders. Sanding
activities place abrasives on road and bridge surfaces
to provide for temporary traction and safer driving.
Temperature suppressant chemicals such as magnesium
chloride (MgCl), are applied as an anti-icer or de-icer,
and for pre-wetting of abrasives, for general winter
maintenance. Winter weather and level of service guidelines
help determine rates of application for abrasives and
winter chemicals.
Currently about ten million tons of road salt is
used each winter in the United States.[N]
A 1994 NCHRP report estimated that North Americans
spend $20 billion annually on snow and ice control.[N]
A more recent report by the New England Transportation
Consortium estimated that winter ice control chemical
application in the U.S. alone totaled $500 million
per year, accounting for one-third of highway winter
maintenance expenditures in the United States.[N]
More effective use of deicer chemical could result
in significant economical and environmental benefits.
While DOTs typically specify and test for heavy metals,
pH and nitrogen/nitrates for all products used for
winter maintenance and try to avoid overuse of all
materials, much of managing the environmental effects
of winter operations comes down to management of salt.
Salt contamination has become a growing issue for some
state DOTs, which have had to purchase contaminated
wells and properties and have had to extend pipes to
municipal water systems. In Canada, salt has become
more heavily regulated by the federal environmental
agency; the Canadian Ministers of the Environment and
of Health therefore recommended adding road salts to
Schedule 1 of Canada's Environmental Protection Act
of 1999. In response, Environment Canada proposed management
measures to minimize the impacts of road salt on the
environment in late 2003.[N]
The Transportation Association of Canada and many
DOTs in the United States have begun to develop best
practices to minimize salt usage and salt entry into
the environment surrounding roads and maintenance facilities.
Along with reduced salt usage and the shift to more
proactive anti-icing methods, sand usage, water and
air quality problems, and roadside vegetation inundation
decrease as well. The stewardship practices are compiled
to help transportation agencies implement a winter
operations program with reduced impacts to the environment
from salt, sand, and other chemicals.
The transition to reduced salt usage has been facilitated
by great improvements in snowfighting equipment and
technology in recent years. Equipment is available
to facilitate precise, controlled applications of material,
at reduced rates established as a result of extensive
research and testing. While much of this new equipment
is more sophisticated, durable, and easier to use,
the potential benefits can be best realized if maintenance
staff are thoroughly trained, material use is closely
monitored, and feedback systems are in place. Increasingly,
application rates are being tied into sensor based
information systems including real time data, weather
forecasts, road friction measurements, road surface
temperature measurements, and global positioning equipment.
As the use of this technology evolves, considerable
planning, organization, and evaluation are required
to ensure the best use of existing technology.
Some DOTs are also taking a closer look at sensitive
areas, for special consideration and/or altered practices.
Such areas include: [N]
- Spawning streams and those inhabited by federally
protected or state listed sensitive aquatic species,
especially trout and other listed or candidate fish.
- Those impaired water segments listed on the state's "Section
303(d) List" for Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL)
Plan development and restoration.
- Those receiving direct runoff from treated roads
and highways where there would be less than 100:1
dilution;
- Those where a large volume of highway runoff can
directly reach small, poorly flushed ponds, lakes
and wetlands.
- Those where receiving water temperatures have
warmed by the time highway runoff arrives.
This chapter on environmental stewardship practices
in winter operations will first identify recommended
practices for strategic planning for reduced salt usage,
and then look at initiatives by leading DOTs, and practices
and accomplishments in specific program areas to achieve
such reductions and improve environmental outcomes. |